Lizzie Borden’s Mental Health: Facts and Psychology

Illustration accompanying the Lizzie Borden mental health and psychology analysis

A psychological profile of Lizzie Borden can raise interesting questions about evidence, public opinion and storytelling. Can it reliably tell us what was happening in her mind more than a century ago?

Can we truly understand someone’s mental health more than a century after their death by examining a few court records, newspaper reports, and a Netflix series?

The short answer is no. The longer answer lies within the details that still make the Lizzie Borden case so fascinating today.

Lizzie Borden’s name became forever associated with two brutal murders committed in the United States in 1892.

Her father, Andrew Borden, and her stepmother, Abby Borden, were found murdered in their Massachusetts home. Lizzie was soon accused, arrested, and brought to trial.

On June 20, 1893, a jury found her not guilty. The Library of Congress timeline records the murders on August 4, 1892, her arrest on August 11, and the subsequent trial and acquittal.

Legally, the murders remained unsolved. Yet public opinion never truly acquitted Lizzie Borden.

For more than a century, people have continued to ask the same questions: Was Lizzie Borden really guilty? If she was, what could have driven her to such extreme violence? What was Lizzie Borden’s mental health really like? Did her calm behaviour suggest that she was hiding something, or was it simply the controlled manner expected of women during the Victorian era?

Netflix’s Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story, released on September 17, 2026, has brought this old mystery back into the public eye.

The official Netflix announcement presents a dramatic interpretation of the story. Its narrative choices do not change the historical outcome: Lizzie Borden was tried and acquitted.

Who Was Lizzie Borden?

Lizzie Andrew Borden was born in Fall River, Massachusetts, in 1860. Her father, Andrew Borden, was a wealthy businessman who owned several properties and investments.

However, he was also known for being extremely frugal, and the family lived a much simpler life than their wealth might have allowed.

Lizzie’s biological mother died when she was young. Her father later married Abby Gray. Lizzie and her older sister, Emma, reportedly had a complicated relationship with their stepmother. Property and inheritance disagreements are believed to have caused tension within the household, although it is impossible to know exactly how serious those conflicts were.

On the morning of August 4, 1892, Abby Borden was found dead upstairs, while Andrew Borden was discovered on a sofa downstairs.

Both had been killed with a sharp weapon, believed to have been a hatchet. Investigators concluded that the murders had taken place within a relatively short period.

There were no obvious signs that someone had forced their way into the house. Because Lizzie was at home around the time of the murders, suspicion quickly turned toward her.

Lizzie Borden was arrested on August 11, 1892. There was no eyewitness, no murder weapon that could be conclusively linked to her, and no indisputable physical evidence.

The prosecution’s case relied heavily on circumstantial evidence, alleged contradictions in Lizzie’s statements, and interpretations of her behaviour.

Contemporary reports of the trial also show that the case was shaped as much by public opinion and conflicting testimony as it was by actual evidence.

Can We Build a Psychological Profile of Lizzie Borden?

The public material discussed here does not establish a verified psychiatric diagnosis. The sources linked below are historical reporting and a modern screen synopsis, rather than clinical interviews or standardised psychological assessments.

A retrospective profile built from these materials is different from a clinical evaluation. It can explore competing interpretations, but it cannot reliably establish a diagnosis.

For this reason, diagnosing Lizzie Borden with psychopathy, antisocial personality disorder, dissociative identity disorder, depression, or any other psychiatric condition would not be scientifically responsible.

A diagnosis cannot be based solely on how someone appeared or behaved during one event. Mental health professionals need to examine a person’s life history, thoughts, feelings, relationships, and long-term behavioural patterns.

The surviving information about Lizzie’s life comes mainly from court documents, sensational newspaper reports, and the accounts of other people.

These sources were not entirely objective. Some reflected the prosecution’s efforts to prove that she was guilty. Others came from supporters who strongly believed in her innocence.

Newspapers also had a commercial reason to make the story as dramatic and shocking as possible.

Attempting to diagnose Lizzie Borden today would be like looking at a few old photographs and believing that we understand an entire human life.

Is Appearing Calm a Sign of Guilt?

Lizzie Borden’s behaviour has been debated for generations. Some observers claimed that she did not appear upset enough after the murders. Others pointed to inconsistencies in her answers and described her as surprisingly calm.

However, calm behaviour alone is not proof of guilt.

People do not all respond to fear, shock, or trauma in the same way. Some cry uncontrollably.

Others cannot speak. Some become restless, while others appear unusually calm or emotionally distant. Responses to extreme stress can vary. The National Institute of Mental Health describes a range of reactions after trauma, including changes in mood, sleep and concentration. This general information does not establish which reactions Lizzie experienced.

Someone is not automatically a psychopath because they calmly drink a cup of tea, just as crying does not automatically make someone innocent.

It is also important to remember that women in the late nineteenth century were expected to control their emotions, behave modestly in public, and avoid exposing private family matters. Lizzie’s calmness may seem unusual to us today, but it may have carried a different meaning within the social expectations of her time.

The deeper issue is that the human mind dislikes uncertainty.

When we cannot find a clear answer, we begin to magnify small behaviours, analyse facial expressions, and fill in the missing pieces with our own stories.

This may be one reason the Lizzie Borden case has become an endless cycle of overthinking.

Could Suppressed Anger Explain the Murders?

Netflix’s official synopsis emphasises a household shaped by humiliation and cruelty. That framing offers a way to discuss the fictional character’s anger; it is not a clinical record of the historical Lizzie.

The interpretation draws on accounts of family tensions, but those accounts do not establish her private emotional state. Lizzie was in her early thirties, unmarried, and financially dependent on her father.

Although she was an adult by modern standards, the degree of control she had over her own life remains open to debate.

Property disputes, tension with her stepmother, and the narrow social boundaries placed on women during the Victorian era may have created considerable frustration and anger.

However, we cannot conclude that she committed murder simply because she may have experienced suppressed anger.

Anger is an emotion, not evidence of a crime. Family pressure, unhappiness, and trauma do not automatically turn someone into a violent offender.

Millions of people experience painful family situations without harming anyone.

Psychology may help us understand possible emotional processes, but it cannot act as a magical detective that replaces missing evidence.

When discussing Lizzie Borden’s mental health, we must separate psychological possibilities from historical facts. She may have been angry, unhappy, or emotionally trapped. None of those possibilities proves that she committed the murders.

Why Is the “Psychopath” Label Misleading Here?

True crime stories have created a familiar habit: whenever someone’s behaviour appears difficult to understand, people quickly label that person a psychopath.

In reality, psychopathy is far more complex than the popular idea of a cold or evil person.

It cannot be identified from the way someone looks at a camera, remains silent in court, or behaves at a funeral.

People who believe Lizzie was guilty interpret her calmness as emotional coldness. Those who believe she was innocent explain the same behaviour as an attempt to remain strong.

The interesting part is that the same behaviour can be used to support two completely different conclusions.

This tells us more about our own minds than it does about Lizzie.

Confirmation bias and the stories we choose

Once we have decided what we believe about someone, we may give more weight to information that supports our original opinion. The APA definition of confirmation bias describes this tendency to favour supporting evidence while overlooking conflicting evidence.

If we believe a person is guilty, their silence appears suspicious. If they speak too much, we assume they are trying to manipulate us. If they cry, we say they are acting. If they do not cry, we call them heartless.

Whatever the person does, they cannot escape the story we have already created about them.

Lizzie Borden has been trapped inside this psychological pattern for more than a century.

Why Does Female Anger Make Society So Uncomfortable?

One reason the Lizzie Borden case continues to fascinate people is that the accused woman appeared to fit the Victorian image of a respectable lady.

Women were generally viewed as gentle, obedient, caring, and naturally distant from violence. The accusation that a wealthy, religious, and outwardly composed woman had committed such a brutal crime created a cultural shock.

On one side was the belief that a woman could never commit such an act. On the other was the idea that if she had done it, she could not possibly be a “normal” woman.

Both attitudes reduced Lizzie to a social category instead of recognising her as a complicated human being.

She had to be either completely innocent and fragile or a cold, inhuman monster.

Some of the speculation surrounding Lizzie Borden’s mental health also comes from this rigid way of thinking. Rather than recognising female anger as an ordinary human emotion, society often tries to explain it through madness, illness, or evil.

Anger does not belong exclusively to men. Women can also feel resentment, hatred, frustration, and even fantasies of revenge.

Experiencing these emotions does not mean that someone will act upon them.

Does the Netflix Series Present Facts or an Interpretation?

Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story is a dramatic production, not a documentary. It fills historical gaps with invented conversations, imagined motivations, and fictional scenes.

A screen portrayal can suggest motives and construct a coherent story, but it cannot prove that the historical Lizzie Borden was guilty. The official Netflix synopsis is a description of the programme, rather than independent evidence about Lizzie’s mental health.

Real historical cases often contain questions that can never be answered. Fiction, however, is uncomfortable with empty spaces. A television series needs to give its audience a story with a beginning, a development, and a conclusion.

As a result, questions that remain unanswered in real life are often given definite answers on screen.

The problem is not that the series contains fictional elements. The problem begins when viewers confuse dramatic storytelling with historical evidence.

Lizzie Borden’s mental health may also have been interpreted in ways designed to create a more compelling character.

Suppressed anger, trauma, and family control may offer meaningful ways to analyse a fictional version of Lizzie. However, such an analysis is not the same as a historical psychiatric evaluation.

Was Lizzie Borden Really Guilty?

Psychology cannot give us a definitive answer.

Certain circumstances were considered suspicious. Lizzie was at home around the time of the murders, some of her statements were described as inconsistent, and tensions within the family were presented as a possible motive.

However, there was no eyewitness. No murder weapon was conclusively connected to Lizzie. The physical evidence was weak by modern standards, and several aspects of the investigation remain controversial.

The jury ultimately concluded that the prosecution had failed to prove her guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

The most honest answer, therefore, is simple: We do not know.

Perhaps Lizzie was guilty. Perhaps someone else committed the murders. Perhaps a detail that was overlooked or lost would have changed the entire case.

The human mind is uncomfortable with the words “we do not know.” Yet sometimes, that is the most accurate and scientifically responsible answer available.

What Can the Lizzie Borden Case Teach Us?

We cannot give Lizzie Borden a reliable mental health diagnosis. However, her case can teach us a great deal about how people interpret human behaviour.

A person’s facial expression, silence, or failure to appear as upset as society expects does not prove guilt.

Trauma does not automatically lead to violence. Being angry or unhappy within a family does not make someone a murderer.

Popular television series can bring historical cases back into public discussion, but dramatic productions cannot replace historical evidence.

A story may feel emotionally convincing without being factually true.

Perhaps the Lizzie Borden case remains so powerful not simply because of the brutality of the murders, but because the story never received a definite ending.

Lizzie Borden was acquitted, but the trial in the public imagination never ended. With every new book, film, and television series, the case begins again.

People examine the same evidence, interpret the same behaviour in different ways, and create their own versions of Lizzie Borden.

The most honest assessment of Lizzie Borden’s mental health begins with admitting that we do not know what was happening inside her mind.

What we do know is how people create stories in response to uncertainty, how society attempts to understand female anger, and how easily we interpret another person’s behaviour through the lens of our own beliefs.

Perhaps the true psychological subject of the Lizzie Borden mystery is not Lizzie herself, but those of us who have spent more than a century trying to solve her.

Frequently Asked Questions

Was Lizzie Borden convicted of murder?

No. She was tried for the murders of Andrew and Abby Borden and acquitted on June 20, 1893. The acquittal is a documented historical outcome; it does not identify who committed the murders.

What mental illness did Lizzie Borden have?

The public material discussed in this article does not establish a verified psychiatric diagnosis. A newspaper description, a photograph or a dramatised performance cannot provide a reliable clinical assessment.

Can calm behaviour prove that someone is guilty?

No. A visible reaction alone cannot establish guilt or a psychiatric condition. People may respond differently to distress, and an observer’s interpretation is separate from evidence about the event.

Is Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story a documentary?

It is a dramatic screen interpretation. Netflix’s official description sets out the programme’s narrative; historical conclusions should be checked against historical records rather than inferred from scenes or dialogue.

Who killed Lizzie Borden’s parents?

The case remains unresolved. Lizzie’s acquittal and the continuing public debate are documented, but the evidence discussed here does not support naming a proven perpetrator.

Related Articles

Sources and References

Historical events, screen storytelling and psychological interpretation are distinguished throughout this article. The discussion does not establish a diagnosis for Lizzie Borden.

WhatsApp

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *