What Is Infidelity? Trust, Boundaries, and Responsibility

At the beginning of their relationship, Duru and Ekin agree to be romantically exclusive. Months later, Duru finds out that Ekin has been exchanging romantic messages with someone else for weeks. Ekin says they never met in person. Duru asks a different question. “If you knew this mattered to our agreement, why did you keep it from me?” The kind of contact, the promise they made, and the decision to hide it each matter.

Infidelity can be understood as sexual or romantic involvement with another person that breaches the expectations of fidelity in a relationship. Partners may have discussed those expectations explicitly, or they may have understood them through the promises they made and how the relationship developed. To make sense of a particular event, it helps to know what happened and what the people in that relationship understood their agreement to be.

What counts as infidelity in a relationship?

In a methodological review, researchers Adrian Blow and Kelley Hartnett found that infidelity studies used different definitions. Some focused on sexual activity. Others included emotional involvement, romantic contact, or behavior that a partner kept secret. A study’s definition determines which events get counted and how its results can be interpreted.

The distinction matters in everyday life too. Confiding in a friend about a problem can be part of a friendship. Sustaining a romantic exchange can raise a different question, especially when both partners understood romantic exclusivity to cover online conversations. Three questions help make the situation more concrete. What did the partners discuss? How did they understand it? What happened afterward?

Relationship agreements can also take different forms. Some partners choose sexual and romantic exclusivity. Others agree to different boundaries by mutual consent. In either case, each person needs to know what they have agreed to and what should be discussed when the terms change. Read more about healthy boundaries.

When the boundary was unclear

One person may take a flirtatious exchange to be an obvious boundary violation while their partner understood the situation differently. The words they used are one part of that history. Previous conversations, mutual expectations, and what each person agreed to disclose when things changed can also help clarify what both understood.

If the partners disagree about what to call the event, they can still discuss what happened and what each person needs now. Naming the point of disagreement can show whether they are prepared to make a clearer agreement in the future.

Privacy and concealment

People can have private thoughts, confidential conversations with friends, and personal time within an honest relationship. Concealment becomes relevant when the information would help the other person make an important choice about their own relationship. The distinction is easier to see when you ask how the missing information relates to a shared agreement.

In Duru and Ekin’s case, access to every message is a separate issue. The more direct question is whether a boundary was understood and whether both people had the information they needed when making decisions about staying together. Hiding a choice can affect trust alongside the choice itself.

Why do people report being unfaithful?

Dylan Selterman, Justin Garcia, and Irene Tsapelas surveyed 495 people who reported having been unfaithful. Most were young adults. Their responses described a range of motives, including anger, feeling neglected, a desire for variety, sexual desire, lower commitment, and circumstances that shaped a particular decision. The variety matters because a single explanation misses much of what people report about their own experiences.

The study relied on people recalling and describing past behavior. Those reports can help researchers understand the explanations participants give. They offer a limited basis for predicting an individual’s behavior or assigning a definite cause from the outside. Someone may say they felt distant from their partner. That is one account of the circumstances. Responsibility for the decision involves a separate question.

Two people in similarly unhappy relationships may choose very different actions. One might raise the difficulty directly, another might ask to renegotiate the relationship, and another might leave. A discussion of motives can clarify how a person understood their options and what they are willing to do differently. What someone chose to do remains part of that discussion.

Honesty and the ability to make a choice

Philosophers distinguish between making a false statement and other ways of misleading someone. In his survey of the philosophy of lying and deception, James Edwin Mahon discusses the different conditions under which these terms apply. A person can sometimes use true statements to lead someone toward a misleading impression, for example by selectively sharing details that make an event appear less consequential than it was.

The same issue can arise outside romance. In a joint project, withholding information that would change a colleague’s decision can limit their ability to choose on informed terms. Failing to disclose that an important promise went unfulfilled can affect a friendship in a similar way. Honesty gives the other person a fairer chance to understand the situation and decide what they want to agree to.

It is possible to give yourself a selective account of what happened too. “Nobody was affected” may be an assumption about other people’s experiences. Asking what you actually know and what you are assuming helps you examine your own explanation. Read about wishful thinking in relationships.

What can you discuss after a breach of trust?

Two adults walk side by side along a tree-lined path while talking
An open conversation can give both people room to describe what happened and what they need.

John Rempel, John Holmes, and Mark Zanna described aspects of trust in close relationships that include predictability, dependability, and confidence in a partner’s future conduct. After a breach, people may revisit the past behavior they took as evidence of trust. What counts as meaningful evidence now can depend on what happened and what each person needs.

A conversation can separate the event, its effects, and the decision ahead. Each calls for a different kind of information.

  • The event. What boundary had the partners discussed, and what action is known to have taken place? Identify the details that both can describe and the ones that are still unclear.
  • The effects. Which expectation or plan did the behavior change? Give the other person room to describe the effect in their own words, even if there are questions about the original intent.
  • The future. What responsibility is the person prepared to take? What boundaries and specific actions can each partner discuss? The decision to continue a relationship belongs to both people, and each may reach it at a different pace.

One person may say they did not anticipate the impact. The other can describe the difference it made to their decisions. Listening closely to that account is a separate skill from giving an explanation. Read more about communication and feeling misunderstood.

Forgiveness, staying together, and trust

Forgiveness may describe a change in how someone relates to the hurt or anger they feel. Staying together is a decision about what both people want and what terms they can agree to now. Trust can depend on whether actions and commitments match over time. These processes can proceed at different rates. A person can be ready to make one decision while still working out how they feel about the others.

Frequently asked questions

Can online contact count as infidelity?

The nature of the contact and the partners’ understanding of fidelity both matter. Romantic content, an ongoing pattern, and any agreements the partners made can help clarify the situation. The meaning of a single message is easier to assess in the context of the conversation and the relationship.

Do relationship problems explain why people are unfaithful?

Some people describe relationship difficulties as part of their motivation. Research also finds other explanations. Understanding how the relationship was going is a different task from establishing which action someone chose and how they will take responsibility for it.

How can you tell whether trust is growing again?

Look at how people handle uncertainty, whether they follow through on commitments, and how boundaries work in daily life. What counts as meaningful change depends on the breach and the conditions each partner needs in order to feel able to continue.

References

  • Blow, A. J., and Hartnett, K. (2005). Infidelity in Committed Relationships I. Journal of Marital and Family Therapy, 31(2), 183–216. Methodological review.
  • Selterman, D., Garcia, J. R., and Tsapelas, I. (2019). Motivations for Extradyadic Infidelity Revisited. Journal of Sex Research, 56(3), 273–286. Study.
  • Rempel, J. K., Holmes, J. G., and Zanna, M. P. (1985). Trust in Close Relationships. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 49(1), 95–112. Article.
  • Mahon, J. E. The Definition of Lying and Deception. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Philosophical background.
WhatsApp

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *